Wednesday 1 February 2017

Newspaper column 1 February 2017 - Cornwall Council's Truro City of Culture fiasco

Last week the group in charge of Cornwall Council, comprising ten senior Liberal Democrat and Independent councillors forming a Cabinet under leader John Pollard, voted, 9-1, to spend a minimum of £536,000 of Cornish taxpayer money on a bid for Truro to be the European Capital of Culture for 2023. If successful the bid will cost as much as £25million in total.

Regular readers of my column will know that I am not shy to hold Cornwall Council to account.
As an organisation they do many good things, and just last week I was pleased to get an update on them on the work that is taking place for the invaluable A30-A391 link road, the upgrading of the A3058 and the continued excellent progress of Cornwall’s bus service devolution.

However the current leadership at Cornwall Council has been, in my view, making increasingly baffling decisions on how to use your money for the good of Cornwall. This is the latest one.

Those in Cornwall Council’s leadership often tell me, during my regular meetings with them, that they have no money for essential work and services, running from filling potholes to keeping public toilets open. They publicly blame central government cuts on their issues. True, cuts have been made and we all have to tighten our belts. However Cornwall Council is a colossal organisation with a massive budget and as I have said in the past, it needs to take some responsibility for it. To plead poverty in this way, but once again find funding for a pet project is not, to me, the right way to run things.

Of course, this is just another in a growing list of waste of money projects by the Council’s leadership to add to the now infamous bus lane to nowhere and the recent three quarters of a million pounds on a pointless car parking consultation, the results of which I now understand they have kicked into the long grass.

Looking at the papers that the Cabinet voted on there appears to be a lot of support for the move from various organisations around Cornwall for the bid. Indeed, many of them wax lyrical about the benefits the bid, if successful will bring. However what they have all failed to do is commit any money whatsoever to the scheme, leaving Cornwall Council as currently the only funder.

Some say that you have to spend money to make money but I believe, at a time where they say they don’t have money to maintain the most basic public services, Cornwall Council should be prioritising its spending away from projects like this and focusing on what matters. It isn’t their money after all, it is yours.

Of course, apart from anything else, come 2023 we won’t even be in the European Union. Could you see President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker deciding to come along to open Truro as the centre of European Union ideals and culture, at a time that could be five years after we have left the EU?


This decision is a speculative gamble with taxpayers’ money at a time when the Council should have other priorities. My hope is that they will listen to common sense and reverse this decision before any money is wasted.